Choose SMT when the board goes through reflow only, the connector sees no mechanical pull, and volume justifies the coplanarity risk. Choose through-hole when a cable pulls on the part, when the board goes through wave solder anyway, or when the assembly will be reworked by hand. If both are true, use a hybrid part with SMT pads for location and through-hole pins for strength.

Most arguments about SMT versus through-hole are about electrical performance, and that argument is usually wasted. At 2.54 mm pitch and 3 A per pin, both variants have the same contact resistance and the same current rating. What differs is how the part survives your process and your field.

What reflow does to a plastic body

An SMT header goes through the full reflow profile: roughly 150 seconds above 217 °C and a peak of 245–260 °C. The housing has to hold its shape through that without warping, and the tails have to stay coplanar.

That is why SMT headers are molded in PA6T or LCP rather than PBT. PBT softens well below the reflow peak. A PBT part that is "SMT" on the drawing will come out of the oven with tails lifted a few tenths of a millimetre, and you will find the open joints at functional test, not at AOI.

Coplanarity is the SMT tax

Coplanarity is the maximum vertical deviation of all tails from one plane. For a 2.54 mm SMT header we hold 0.10 mm; fine pitch parts need better. Anything worse and the paste volume has to compensate, which means either a solder ball or an open joint depending on which way the tail leaned.

  • Long headers, 2×20 and above, are the hard case: the molding has to stay flat across 50 mm.
  • Tube packaging protects coplanarity; a bulk bag does not. If you are buying SMT parts in bags, expect bent tails.
  • A single reflow pass is fine. A second pass for the bottom side reflows the first side again; check that the housing tolerates it.

Through-hole is still the answer for cables

A through-hole pin sits in a plated hole with solder all the way around it. When someone pulls a cable out at an angle, the load goes into the board through the barrel, not through a 0.5 mm pad-to-track joint. That is why anything a technician unplugs repeatedly is still through-hole in most industrial designs, twenty years after SMT took over everything else.

Through-hole also survives hand rework. If your assembly flow includes touching up joints with an iron, an SMT header will not enjoy it. The pads lift before the plastic complains.

The hybrid option

Hybrid headers have SMT pads at the ends for location during placement and through-hole pins for mechanical retention. They solve the two problems separately: the pads hold the part flat through reflow, the pins take the insertion force. The cost is a slightly larger footprint and a mixed process on the line.

Can I reflow a through-hole header?

Yes, with a pin-in-paste process: paste is printed into the holes and the part is placed like an SMT part. It needs longer pins, a specific stencil aperture and a reflow profile that wets inside the barrel. It works, but it is a process engineering task, not a drop-in substitution.

Does SMT reduce the current rating?

No, the pin and plating set the rating. What changes is heat paths: a through-hole pin conducts into the board through the barrel, an SMT tail only through the joint. At 3 A that difference does not matter; at 8 A it does.

Which is cheaper at 10,000 pieces?

SMT, usually, because the part is placed by the machine and there is no second soldering step. Below a few thousand pieces the difference is small and the process risk of SMT is not worth it.

Send the board thickness, the reflow profile and a note on whether a cable is plugged in during service, and we will quote the variant that fits the process rather than the one that is easier to sell. Both types are in the pin header range.