Qualify the second source against the drawing, not against the incumbent part. Run a first article on both, compare the measured values, and repeat only the tests that the process change can affect: pin retention, plating thickness, coplanarity and mating force. Electrical tests on a passive connector rarely need repeating.
The qualification is small if the drawing is good. It becomes a project when the drawing says "2.54 mm header, 2×10, gold" and nothing else, because then you are comparing two interpretations, not two processes.
Start with the drawing, not the samples
Before asking anyone for samples, check that the drawing specifies: contact material and plating thickness on contact area and tail, housing material with a UL file reference, pin retention force, coplanarity for SMT parts, and the dimensional tolerances that matter to your assembly.
- If the drawing says "gold plated", you cannot compare two quotes. Fix that first.
- If the housing material is open, a PBT part will be quoted against a PA6T part and both will look compliant.
- If coplanarity is not stated, a tape-and-reel part and a tube part both pass.
What to actually measure
| Characteristic | Why it matters | Repeat on second source |
|---|---|---|
| Pin retention force | Predicts field failures | Yes |
| Plating thickness, contact and tail | Wear life and solderability | Yes |
| Coplanarity | SMT yield | Yes, SMT only |
| Insertion and withdrawal force | Assembly feel, wear | Yes |
| Body dimensions | Fits the enclosure | Yes |
| Contact resistance | Baseline sanity | Once, both parts |
The cross-reference trap
"Equivalent to brand X" is the most expensive phrase in connector sourcing. Two parts can share a footprint and differ in contact alloy, spring geometry and plating underplate. The differences show up as insertion force and as wear life, neither of which appears on a datasheet comparison.
Ask for the three numbers: contact material, plating thickness with underplate, and insertion force per pin. If a supplier cannot give all three, they are not ready to be a second source.
Running both sources
Once qualified, do not switch 100% of volume on day one. Run 20–30% through the new source for two or three production lots and watch the assembly first-pass yield. Connector problems appear as a yield dip at the placement or test station, not as a return.
Keep the incumbent qualified even after the switch. The point of a second source is availability, and that only works if both are still approved when you need the second one.
How long does qualification take?
With a complete drawing, two to three weeks: samples in 2 working days, first article in a week, then one production lot. Without a complete drawing, add a month for the arguments.
Do I need to requalify the whole product?
Usually not. If the connector is a passive interconnect and the drawing is held, a first article plus the mechanical tests above is proportionate. Check with your customer or certifying body if the product is regulated.
Is a cheaper second source worth the risk?
Only if the saving survives the qualification cost. On a $0.20 part at 10,000 pieces a year, a 15% saving is $300, which does not pay for the engineering time. The reason to second-source is supply security, not price.
Send the drawing you have, even if it is incomplete, and we will tell you which gaps will stop a fair comparison. Capability and tooling are described under capabilities; the plating specification is covered in gold thickness.